Thursday, May 14, 2009

The Incident

Sorry to be posting a little late . . . I had to let it all digest.

While it wasn’t my favorite finale, it definitely got me thinking (and, of course, opened up a whole new can of worms). The whole Jacob thing is really blowing my mind today!
I also spent too much time reading about Jacob the biblical figure and his brother Esau.

1. Is it just me, or is Jacob a regular Rumplestilsken?

2. Jacob and his nemesis (unnamed thus far) watch beside the statue as the Black Rock sails toward the coast of the island. Nemesis says, “We brought them here. It always the same: they come, they fight, they destroy.” Jacob replies, “It only ends once. Everything else is just progress.”
-- Nemesis’ words seem to describe all groups that come to the island. In some ways, isn’t it the perfect description of mankind? Could it be that Nemesis and Jacob are opposing viewpoints on mankind? Good v. evil? Optimism v. Pessimism?
-- Chris called it – Jacob lies in the shadow of the statue (more on that later).

3. THIS WEEK IN BIBLE STUDIES: This could take a while, so I am going to include a link to Wikipedia and just give you a few highlights:
a. Jacob had a twin named Esau. Esau was born first, with Jacob clinging to his heel. Esau was initially favored by his father Isaac (who later was renamed Israel), but because of a trick by their mother, Jacob became the blessed one. During this trick, Rebecca disguised Jacob as Esau (Jacob was fair, Esau was hairy, Isaac was blind).
b. Esau spent most of the rest of his life seeking revenge on Jacob and his descendants.
c. Jacob and his wife Rachel (Juliet’s sister’s name)struggled for nearly 100 years to conceive a child, but eventually bore two sons (he had 8 others w/ other wives), including Joseph and Benjamin (awwww . . . snap). That’s why Ben feels so forsaken by his island “father”? He is always the “second son.”
d. In both Jewish and Islamic faith, Jacob is the one chosen by God to spread his word.
e. Here’s the link if you want to read more:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jacob

My conclusion? Jacob really is goodness . . . but he is also seeking the “end” of the story.

4. Jacob’s “touching” of the 06:
a. Kate – trying to steal a lunch box – Jacob protects her from being punished (possibly protecting her from her stepdad?) – Kate eventually becomes an outlaw -- ends up on island.
b. James – Jacob gives him the pen to write his letter to Mr. Sawyer – James carries this letter with him always – He becomes Sawyer, a con-man, just like the one who “killed” his parents – ends up on island.
c. Sayid – Jacob asks him for directions and he pauses while Nadia continues to cross and is hit by a car and killed – Sayid no longer has any reason to repress his “killer instinct – he goes back to the island
d. Locke – Jacob is reading outside the building from which Locke was pushed – he touches Locke and tells him everything will be ok and that he is sorry this happened to him – he ends up on the island (Locke did have some important role on the island. Nemesis somehow knew this . . . used it to his advantage).
e. Sun and Jin’s wedding – Jacob shakes their hands and tells them “your love is special. Never take it for granted.” -- Sun comes back to island to find Jin.
f. Jack – After Sarah’s surgery, Jack flips on Christian (who questions whether it is really Christian who doesn’t believe in Jack) – Jacob hands Jack the Apollo bar – Jack’s dysfunctional relationship with his father and his self doubt – ends up on island.
g. Hurley – Jacob is pretty honest with him – tells him he is lucky not cursed because he can talk to the dead – gives him guitar – Hurley goes back to island. (This also helps us understand Hurley’s more light-hearted outlook on speaking w/ the dead, particularly when he talks with Miles).

Jacob has touched the lives of all these people. I think “they” are the “they” who are coming! They are all an integral part of Jacob’s plan. He is helping them fulfill their destinies.

5. Ilana and company – disciples of Jacob. How did this come to pass? What is the back story there?

6. RECURRING LINE: “What’s done is done.”

7. James asks Jack what he wants, for every man “does what he does for a reason.” Jack implies it is because he lost Kate.

8. James and Juliet were really pissing me off for a while there . . . but in the end . . . James+Juliet=4Ever!

9. YOU SHOULD LISTEN TO MILES!!!: “Did it ever occur to you that you may cause the thing you are trying to prevent?” Maybe that’s why “they’re coming.”

10. PHIL = CREEPER!

11. For what is Frank a candidate? A disciple? They seem to think he will be trustworthy. Are they trust worthy? (They being Ilana and Bram)

12. TEAR-JERKER MOMENT: Do I even have to say it? “Don’t you leave me.” “I will always love you.” So unfair!

13. THIS WEEK IN LOST LITERATURE: Everything That Rises Must Converge: This short story tells place in the recently desegregated South, where "enlightened" whites are condescending, and blacks resent the efforts of well-meaning whites. The collection deals with what happens when things change, how we must face up to our problems and confront our own hypocrisies.

14. Jacob tells Ben he has a CHOICE. Of course, Ben CHOOSES to kill Jacob (his “father”)

15. Totally knew it was going to be Locke in the box. Interestingly, that is the same ending as last year . . . hmmmmm . . .

16. Richard saves Ellie – “Consequences” of our actions.

17. Holla to Rose and Bernard! You, too, Vincent!

18. Richard asks Jack about Locke. Jack has a surprising new outlook on John – He says he wouldn’t give up on him.

19. Why did everyone change their minds and help Jack with his mission? Boy, is Sawyer gonna hate his guts for real now!

20. What lies in the shadow of the statue? "Ille qui nos omnes servabit" - “He who will protect/save us all.”

21. “They’re Coming” -- WHO? I think the 06. I think the bomb will actually set it all in motion – again. I think Miles was right.

22. Every season ends with a bang. Literally!

23. Questions I’m still dying to find the answers to:
a. Where is Claire?
b. What role does Christian play? (Could he be the form that Nemesis took before John’s body arrived?)
c. Why can’t babies be born on the island after Dharmaville?
d. Walt . . . will he be back?
e. Why doesn’t Richard age?
f. Who built the statue?

24. New Questions:
a. Who is Jacob’s enemy (aka Nemesis)?
b. Why does he want to kill Jacob?
c. What is the loophole? How does Locke fit into it?
d. How does Jacob "bring" people to the Island?
e. Why did Jacob choose to visit each person at pivotal moments of their lives?
f. Who did Locke and Hurley see/hear previously at the cabin? (Nemesis?)
g. Who are
Ilana and her crew, and why are they referring to themselves as "the good guys?"
h. For what and why is Frank a candidate?
i. Why had Jacob never met with Ben? (he seemed to imply cause Ben is an insipid whiner sometimes)
j. How did Jacob come to be on the Island?
k. Who are "they" that are coming?

Finally, in the 2010 teaser, “Destiny Revealed,” a female eye opens. It looked like Juliet’s to me . . . but I guess we’ll have to wait 7 months to find out!

Namaste,
LLL

8 comments:

LoyalLostLoser said...

Two things -- Kate is with Tom in the store. The lunchbox is the same one they dug up as adults.

Jacob was cooking red herring on a black rock. Ha!

Anonymous said...

In true "Juliet" style, she sacrifies herself for her man.

I quite enjoyed the episode, so I don't know what your beef is, LLL...

I think of Jacob as being God Himself (dressed in white at the beginning), while the other guy (dressed in black) is Lucifer. Similarly, I think of the island as a Garden of Eden, which is corrupted by man but which God is not willing to give up on, though He also doesn't want to directly affect it either. He's letting man/the world progress slowly with him only as a guide. Does he know Ben will kill him? Why would his daughter

The "loophole" is confusing. It may have something to do with the fact that Locke is dead while on the plane. Perhaps the Lucifer dude can take on his shape for that reason and not anyone else's, just like he can't directly kill Jacob, but can convince someone else to do it (Ben).

I have to think, based on next season's subtitle, that they will all end up on that plane or in some other situation that will bring them all together. Is that their destiny...to meet and affect each other's lives?

Rob

Anonymous said...

Oops...incomplete thought. Why would Ben's daughter tell him to listen to Locke? I guess that was Lucifer setting him up, huh?

Rob again

SinD said...

Thanks, Kate!
I like the good/evil Jacob theory - and this episode. Nice call on Rose and Bernard, btw. Yay for them!
Questions:
How can Jacob be killed by Ben - it seems like he was suggesting that he couldn't be killed - or maybe just not by nemesis, which is why Locke picked Ben - and who better to murder all things good than Ben? I don't think Jacob is dead.
Maybe nemesis was using Christian's body the same way he was using Locke's since Christian arrived in the casket the first time? Is Locke completely gone? He knew everything about himself, so if he's been taken over by nemesis, maybe Locke is still in there and will fight to come back and overcome nemesis?
My favorite line - Locke to Ben: Let me ask you a question.
Ben: I'm a pisces.
Great season, LLR!! What do we do now???
Cyndi

LoyalLostLoser said...

Why was Juliet touching her belly? Is she preggers? Cause that would suck!

Merianne said...

Hey!! I agree with Cyndi. I think the guy talking to Jacob in the first scene is using people's dead bodies. But who is to say Jacob won't do the same thing now that he is "dead"? Jacob could come back using Jack's body or something - then a face off between Jack and Locke!! Now it makes sense that Christian was coming back from the dead. He was just a vehicle for "Lucifer."

And perhaps Richard is the same thing because he doesn't seem to age either.

I did feel kind of bad for Ben. He is right, he protected the island without question. Just did it. And with no reward of any kind. But as the Bible is predicated on the concept of, "it's not about you." There is a book that is floating around church groups who's first line is "It's not about you." (I can't remember the name of it.) And that is the underlying lesson of this show. Do things that go beyond yourself.

Speaking of, poor Jack. Finally gets past the whole "there's a reason for everything" thinking and then everyone calls him nuts. Good to see that everyone joined forces with him in the end.

I am still with Miles (how cute he is!) though. What Jack is doing is creating the very thing they are trying to avoid.

I also love Bernard and Rose. They were given lemons and made lemonade. They had a great point. Why does everyone arrive and want to fight one another? Can't we all just get along????

That Lucifer character is one bad dude!

Merianne said...

Just another point though - why wasn't Lucifer able to use any of the bodies that died ON the island?

Anonymous said...

Maybe this will change next season, but after all the build-up about Locke's potential greatness, it was sad to see that he was actually just being used for evil purposes by this nemesis guy....kind of like he has been used and kicked around by others all his life.

Thanks for the great insights all season, LLL!

Sarah I.